Written by Janine Gard – Birth Educator, Writer & Owner of Bellies to Babies Antenatal & Postnatal Classes
The Pressure to Have a “Good Sleeper”
If you’ve ever found yourself at a coffee group, bleary-eyed, clutching your third cup of caffeine for the day, and someone proudly announces, “Oh, my baby’s been sleeping through since six weeks,” this one’s for you!
For new parents, sleep (or the lack of it) becomes a universal obsession. Everyone wants to know how much you’re getting, how long your baby sleeps, and whether they’re a “good” sleeper, as if that somehow measures your success as a parent!
Here’s the truth: babies aren’t meant to sleep through the night, and you’re not doing anything wrong. In fact, what feels hard, messy, and never-ending is actually normal biology at work.
Let’s unpack what’s really going on—and how you can drop the guilt, survive the exhaustion, and care for yourself while your baby does exactly what nature intended.
Why Newborns Don’t Sleep Through the Night
The Science of Baby Sleep
Newborns sleep in short bursts - usually two to four hours at a time - because their tiny stomachs simply can’t hold much milk. Whether breastfed or bottle-fed, they wake frequently to feed, grow, and feel secure.
Babies also spend far more time in light (active) sleep than we, as adults do. This means they’re more easily disturbed but also safer - because frequent waking reduces the risk of breathing irregularities.
Circadian Rhythm - Still Under Construction
Your baby’s internal clock (circadian rhythm) takes weeks, sometimes months, to mature. They don’t yet understand the difference between day and night, which is why the 2 a.m. “let’s party” phase is so common. It’s not misbehaviour. It’s biology. And no amount of perfect bedtime routines will override that in the first few months.
Why Frequent Waking Is Protective
Waking frequently keeps your baby fed, oxygenated, and connected to you. It’s part of their survival instinct. Studies even show that frequent night waking in the early months is linked with healthy brain development.
So when you’re up for the third feed and wondering why your baby “won’t sleep through,” remind yourself - they’re doing exactly what they’re supposed to.
Where the “Sleeping Through the Night” Myth Came From
Ever wondered who decided babies should sleep all night? Spoiler alert - it wasn’t biology. The idea came from old-fashioned advice, changing culture, and a large dash of marketing! In the early 1900s, parents were told not to “spoil” babies by responding too quickly to their cries. Independence was the goal, and the quiet baby who slept alone became the ideal.
By the mid-century, formula feeding and strict routines reinforced that belief. Formula digests more slowly than breast milk, so babies could go longer between feeds - and suddenly, longer sleep stretches were seen as ‘normal’.
Fast forward to the 1980s and 90s, and sleep-training books promised that with the right method, any baby could be “sleeping through the night.” What most people didn’t realise was that phrase originally meant just five hours of sleep, not 12!! Over time, the definition shifted, and so did expectations. Today, “sleeping through” is still seen as the ultimate parenting milestone - but it’s more myth than measure. Babies wake because they need to. It’s protective, natural, and part of how they thrive.
Coping With the Comments (and Protecting Your Mental Health)
The Well-Meaning but Unhelpful Advice
“You just need to let him cry.”
“She’s manipulating you.”
“If you pick her up every time, you’ll spoil her.”
Sound familiar? Most advice comes from love or habit, but it can really land like a punch when you’re already exhausted.
Setting Gentle Boundaries
You can protect your peace without offending Grandma. Try phrases like: “That’s interesting, we’re following what feels right for us.” “Thanks for sharing, but our midwife suggested a different approach.” “We’re focusing on responding to our baby’s needs for now.”
Short, polite, firm. You don’t owe anyone an explanation.
When Guilt Creeps In
You might wonder if you’re “created bad habits.” You aren’t. Babies don’t have the cognitive ability to manipulate - they communicate through need. Responding to them builds trust, not dependence.
If guilt starts whispering that you should be doing more, remember: you’re already doing enough. The measure of good parenting isn’t how long your baby sleeps - it’s how safe and loved they feel.
Protecting Your Mental Health
Sleep deprivation isn’t just tiring - it can shake the foundations of how you feel, think, and cope. You’re adjusting to a brand-new identity, caring for someone who depends on you 24/7, and running on fumes. It’s no wonder that so many new parents feel stretched to breaking point at times.
The early weeks (and months) are meant to be intense. But there’s a big difference between being tired and being completely overwhelmed.
Recognising the Warning Signs
Here are some signs your mental health might need extra care or support:
- You feel persistently sad, hopeless, or numb.
- You find yourself crying often, even when you don’t know why.
- You feel anxious, panicky, or constantly “on edge.”
- You’re having trouble sleeping even when your baby sleeps.
- You’re losing interest in things you usually enjoy.
- You feel disconnected from your baby or partner.
- You’re having thoughts that scare you, or wondering if your family would be better off without you.
If any of these sound familiar, please know this doesn’t make you a bad parent. It means you’re human, and you need support—just like anyone would after surgery, injury, or illness.
Why This Happens
The mix of hormone changes, broken sleep, and emotional adjustment after birth can throw anyone off balance. Combine that with pressure to “enjoy every moment,” and it’s easy to feel like you’re failing when you’re really just depleted.
Your brain is trying to protect you by raising the alarm - it’s saying, I’m running on empty and I need help. Listening to that message early can prevent things from getting worse.
Reframing the Hard Days
It’s okay if some days you simply get through. There’s strength in surviving, even when you don’t feel strong. Try swapping thoughts like “I’m failing” with “I’m doing my best with what I have today.” Because you are.
Parenthood isn’t about perfection—it’s about perseverance, presence, and love, even when you’re running on half a tank.
If there’s one takeaway from this section, let it be this: You matter just as much as your baby. Looking after yourself, is looking after them.
How to Cope with Sleep Disruption
Rethink Rest
You might not get long stretches, but you can still get rest. Lie down during your baby’s naps, even for 20 minutes. Rest counts, even if you don’t sleep.
Share the Load
If you have a partner or support person, tag-team the nights.
- One does the feed; the other resettles.
- Alternate nights or shifts.
Create a Night-Time Rhythm
Keep nights quiet and calm:
- Dim lighting
- Gentle voices
- Minimal stimulation
Lower the Bar
Forget perfect. Forget spotless kitchens. Forget “productive days.” You are keeping a tiny human alive - that’s productivity at its finest.
Ask for Help (and Mean It)
If your friends or family offer help, accept it. It doesn’t have to be ‘grand’, helping with meal prep, picking up a few groceries, or a coffee on the way to see you will help your days feel a little lighter and remind you that you’re not in this alone.
Creating a Gentle Sleep Plan (Without the Guilt)
What Gentle Sleep Support Really Means
Gentle sleep strategies aren’t about “training” a baby—they’re about guiding them when they’re developmentally ready. The focus is on connection, not control.
Start With Predictability, Not Perfection
Babies thrive on rhythm more than routine. Think flexible patterns, not strict schedules.
- Morning: feed, play, nap
- Afternoon: feed, play, nap
- Evening: bath, feed, cuddle, bed
Predictable cues help your baby’s body start recognising sleep signals.
Create a Calm Sleep Environment
- Keep the room dim and quiet.
- Use white noise if it helps drown out household sounds.
- Dress your baby comfortably—not too hot, not too cold.
- Use safe-sleep guidelines (firm, flat surface, no loose blankets).
Respond, Don’t React
If your baby cries, pause and observe before rushing in. Sometimes they just stir or resettle. But if they need comfort, go to them confidently. You cannot spoil a baby with love.
Try This Tonight
Tip 1: Swap “I have to get him to sleep” with “I’ll help him feel calm and safe.” That shift takes the pressure off and reframes your role as guide, not enforcer.
Tip 2: Keep a small “night survival kit” by your bed—water, snacks, burp cloth, spare muslin, phone charger etc
Tip 3: Use affirmation's saying quietly, “This is hard, but it’s temporary.” Or, “We’re learning together.”
Tip 4: Lighten the mood - some nights will end in tears; others will end in laughter. If you can find moments to smile - you’re winning!
Redefining What Success Really Looks Like
By now, you’ve probably realised that everyone has an opinion on baby sleep. There are books promising the perfect routine, online experts selling miracle methods, and family members reminding you how they “had you sleeping through by six weeks.” It’s a lot.
Here’s the truth: there isn’t one right way to do this. Every baby is different. Every parent is different. Every household runs on its own rhythm - and that’s okay!
A “good sleeper” isn’t a baby who does a 12-hour stretch. It’s a baby who feels safe, loved, and comforted when they need you.
And a “good parent”? That’s not the one ticking every box or sticking to every rule. It’s the one who shows up, keeps trying, and loves their baby fiercely—even when they’re running on very little sleep .
You don’t have to be perfect. You just have to be present.
Rest when you can. Laugh when it all goes sideways. Cry when you need to. This phase - though it can feel endless, will pass. And what will last isn’t the sleepless nights; it’s the trust, connection, and love you’re building every single day.
Final Thoughts
If you take one thing away from this, let it be this: there’s nothing wrong with your baby - or with you.
Waking, feeding, cuddling, and needing you in the middle of the night is exactly what newborns are meant to do. It’s not a reflection of your parenting, it’s a reflection of their biology.
So, instead of chasing the idea of a “good sleeper,” focus on connection, comfort, and surviving the season you’re in. The nights might feel long, but they won’t last forever. One day you’ll look back and realise how much strength, patience, and love it took to make it through.
You’re not failing- you’re doing it. One feed, one cuddle, one bleary-eyed night at a time. And that, truly, is what good parenting looks like.
Written by Janine Gard
Janine Gard is a Birth Educator, writer, and mum who has been supporting parents through the wild and wonderful world of pregnancy, birth, and early parenting for over 20 years. With her friendly, down-to-earth approach and great sense of humour, she makes even the most complex topics feel easy to understand and genuinely relatable.
Through her business, Bellies to Babies Antenatal and Postnatal Classes, Janine has helped thousands of families across New Zealand feel calmer, more confident, and better prepared for the journey into parenthood. Her classes and resources combine expert knowledge with honest conversation, laughter, and plenty of “you’ve got this” encouragement.
When she’s not teaching or writing, you’ll usually find her creating something beautiful, dreaming up her next project, or building a new home with her husband.
Links:
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/belliestobabiesnz/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/belliestobabiesclasses
Website: https://belliestobabies.co.nz/